5 Minute Homemade Mayonnaise Recipe • The Prairie Homestead (2024)

5 Minute Homemade Mayonnaise Recipe • The Prairie Homestead (1)

Why go to the trouble of making stuff?

Good question. I’ve ask myself that on occasion, especially when I find myself spending precious time deciphering a recipe for something I could grab at the store in two seconds flat.

Sometimes it’s to avoid toxins or artificial ingredients (like in my homemade fly spray or from-scratch BBQ sauce).

Sometimes it’s because I end up with a superior product than the store-bought version (like in the case of my homemade honey lip balm recipe).

But a lot of the time, I DIY just for the sheer joy of it. Creating is one of my favorite things, whether the creation involveshomemade butter, or homesteading ebooks, or this blog.

Creating energizes me better than a cup of black coffee. There’s something about sitting back to admire a completed projected and being able to say, “Hey– I made that!” I’m a creation addict. And there’s no turning back.

Anyone relate?

The Industrial Age brought us many advances, and I’m thankful for well-stocked stores full of ready-made products when I need them. However, only ever being a consumer robs of us of the pleasure that accompanies producing. And creating. And experimenting. And crafting. And while I don’t feel the need to make/grow/product/create every single tiny thing in my life, any time I can add a new skill to my repertoire, it makes me oh so happy.

Which brings us to homemade mayo.Creamy, rich, decadent homemade mayo.

5 Minute Homemade Mayonnaise Recipe • The Prairie Homestead (2)

Do You Mayo?

In the interest of full transparency, I don’t make homemade mayonnaise all the time. Just keepin’ it real. It’s not something we eat a ton, and so it’s usually easier for me to simply buy it and keep it in the fridge the rare occasions.

But, how cool is it to say you know how to make mayo from scratch? Because you never know when the insatiable urge for mayo will arise when you don’t have any in the fridge. Plus, you can skip out on the less-than-desirable soybean or canola oils present in many of the premade versions.

There are lots of ways to make mayo, but I’ve found my food processor to be the the simplest method. And holy cow, I just discovered the COOLEST thing you guys.

Go get your food processor right now. No really, go get it. I’ll wait.

5 Minute Homemade Mayonnaise Recipe • The Prairie Homestead (3)

Grab the plunger thingie and look at the bottom. Is there a tiny hole? If so, you have a crazy-awesome mayo-making machine at your disposal and you didn’t even know it.

The teeny hole lets the oil drizzle ever-so-slowly into the rest of the mayonnaise mixture so it emulsifies perfectly. It’s borderline miraculous. Technology, y’all. Who woulda thought?

Brought to You By…

(this post contains affiliate links)

5 Minute Homemade Mayonnaise Recipe • The Prairie Homestead (4)This particular homemade mayo recipe is from the book Homegrown & Handmade: A Practical Guide to More Self-Reliant Living by Deborah Niemann.

Deborah does a fantastic job of introducing the reader to the idea of doing what you can to produce more, and this book is a slam-dunk reference for anyone looking to expand their self-reliance, or even just understand the options that are available in the homesteading lifestyle.

Homegrown & Handmade includes chapters on:

  • Growing a sustainable garden
  • Cooking from the sustainable garden
  • Managing a backyard orchard
  • Keeping a backyard poultry flock
  • Starting a home dairy
  • Keeping fiber animals
  • And much more

Now, onto the mayonnaise!

5 Minute Homemade Mayonnaise Recipe • The Prairie Homestead (5)

(From Homegrown & Handmade, used with permission)

You Will Need:

  • 2 eggs
  • 2 tablespoons organic lemon juice (buy it here)
  • 1 teaspoon dry mustard
  • 1/2 teaspoon fine sea salt (buy it here)
  • 1 1/4 cups mild cooking oil (see below for options)

Instructions:

Place the eggs in a food processor or blender and blend for 30 seconds. Add the lemon juice, salt, and dry mustard and blend for an additional 15 seconds.

Slowly drizzle in the oil while the processor or blender runs on high (the slower you drizzle, the thicker the mayo). If the plunger of your food processor lid has the magical hole, simply fill it and let the oil drain out before re-filling with the remainder of the oil.

Blend until the mayo is creamy and thick. Taste and add more lemon juice and/or salt, if needed.

Store in the refrigerator for up to one week.

5 Minute Homemade Mayonnaise Recipe • The Prairie Homestead (6)

5 Minute Homemade Mayonnaise Recipe • The Prairie Homestead (7)

Kitchen Notes:

  • The key to the best-tasting homemade mayonnaise is to use a mild tasting oil, such as light olive oil, sunflower oil, avocado oil, or safflower oil. Skip using straight extra-virgin olive oil–it’s too strong and will overpower it in an unpleasant way. You can also mix oils 50/50 (such as half olive oil/half avocado oil). For a super thick mayo, use half light olive oil and half expeller pressed coconut oil (the kind that does not taste like coconuts– buy it here).
  • Spice up homemade mayo with extra herbs and spices, such as 1 tablespoon parsley, 1 teaspoon dill weed, 1 to 3 teaspoons chili powder, or 1 teaspoon paprika, just to name a few.
  • Any food processor will work, but I have a model similar to this one. (My actual model has been discontinued, I think.)
  • Real mayo does contain raw eggs, so be sure to use eggs from a healthy, reputable source.
  • You can also use a hand blender to make mayo, although I have had the best results with a food processor. You can also use a plain ol’ whisk, but I’m a wimp and my arm gets tired.

P.S. Don’t forget to grab your copy of Homegrown & Handmade for more from-scratch living ideas!

5 Minute Homemade Mayonnaise Recipe • The Prairie Homestead (8)

More DIY Foodie Goodness:

  • Homemade Fruit Popsicles
  • How to Make Sour Cream
  • DIY Herb Seasoning Salt
  • How to Make Cream Cheese
  • Homemade Whipped Cream Frosting
5 Minute Homemade Mayonnaise Recipe • The Prairie Homestead (2024)

FAQs

Why is my homemade mayonnaise runny? ›

the various ingredients used to make the mayonnaise are not room temperature; the ingredients have not been dosed correctly; perhaps you have added too much oil or lemon juice; the ingredients (oil and lemon juice) were not added gradually to the mix.

How long will homemade mayonnaise last in the refrigerator? ›

Made with raw eggs, homemade mayo lasts only one to two weeks. But thanks to its pasteurized eggs, my homemade mayonnaise can last an entire month in the fridge.

Why is homemade mayo not advisable? ›

Homemade mayonnaise is made with raw eggs that will not be cooked. The United States Department of Agriculture does not recommend eating raw shell eggs that are not cooked or undercooked due to the possibility that Salmonella bacteria may be present.

What oil is best for mayonnaise? ›

Safflower, canola, grapeseed and peanut oil all do nicely. Just make sure the oil is at the same temperature as the egg. You can use cold oil and cold eggs, but I found room temperature eggs and oil to be the easiest to work with.

How to thicken up homemade mayonnaise? ›

A common way to thicken homemade mayonnaise is to gradually add more oil while continuously whisking the mixture. Another method is to add a small amount of dijon mustard, which can help to emulsify the ingredients and give the mayonnaise a thicker consistency.

How do you fix homemade mayonnaise that didn't emulsify? ›

How to fix a broken mayo:
  1. In a new container or bowl, crack an egg and mix with an immersion blender or whisk.
  2. While blending or whisking, slowly add the broken mayo. Do this step VERY slowly! Once it starts to thicken, you can start adding more at once. Blend until all is incorporated.
Mar 13, 2023

How to tell if homemade mayonnaise is bad? ›

First, if the mayonnaise has begun to discolor and change into a darker shade of white or a brownish-yellow, that may be a sign that the mayo has gone bad. If the oil has separated, that is also a sign that the condiment is no longer good to eat.

Can I freeze homemade mayonnaise? ›

The short answer is yes. Mayonnaise can be frozen, but don't expect the texture to be the same after it thaws. Mayonnaise is an emulsion—combining ingredients that don't typically mix well together—to create a thick, creamy sauce that you can spread on sandwiches, make ranch dressing or onion dip.

Is homemade mayonnaise worth it? ›

Homemade mayonnaise is more flavorful than the storebought stuff, since it's made with fresher ingredients, like egg yolk and just-squeezed lemon juice. Also, there are no preservatives or stabilizers in homemade mayo, so the texture is creamy and velvety, not squelchy and gelatinous.

Can you eat raw eggs in mayonnaise? ›

Because of the risk of Salmonella being present in raw eggs, the USDA (United States Department of Agriculture) recommends using pasteurized eggs when making homemade mayo, and they claim that you can't pasteurize eggs at home, therefore, you must purchase them from the grocery store.

When should you not eat mayo? ›

Avoid mayonnaise that has mold growing on it. You can also tell it has spoiled if it is yellow or brown in color. Even if your mayo looks okay, check for any acidic, sour, or bitter tastes and smells to be sure it has not gone bad. Unopened mayonnaise is likely to last for up to three months after its "best by" date.

What are the bad ingredients in mayonnaise? ›

Commercial mayonnaise contains at least two-thirds vegetable oil by weight. Most vegetable oils are actually seed oils like soybean or sunflower oil, which are high in omega-6 fats and linked to inflammation, obesity, and other health problems.

Why is my homemade mayo bitter? ›

However, a more promising explanation for the bitterness is the presence of polyphenols, like oleuropein in olive oil, which are known to taste bitter and scientists consider them to be responsible for the bitterness that shows up in olive-oil based mayonnaise.

How do you make mayonnaise taste better? ›

Just a drizzle of peppery extra virgin olive oil or nutty pistachio oil can give your mass-produced mayo depth and flavor, making it taste much more expensive than it is. Add a little bit at a time, whisking after each addition, until it tastes luxurious.

What oil is used in Hellmans mayonnaise? ›

Soybean oil, water, whole eggs and egg yolks, vinegar, salt, sugar, lemon juice, calcium disodium edta (used to protect quality), natural flavors.

Is it safe to eat watery mayonnaise? ›

Sometimes when jars or bottles have not been used for a while there may be some liquid that appears on the surface of the product. If this does happen, please shake your bottle well, or stir your mayonnaise well before using. As long as your product is still within its open shelf life your product is still good to eat.

Can you over mix homemade mayonnaise? ›

That said it is also a method with little to no margin of error for the consistency; it is completely possible to overmix mayonnaise when making it at such a high speed. If that happens thin it out with water while mixing with a wire whisk.

How does mayonnaise get its consistency? ›

O/W emulsions are prepared by simply blending an oil phase into a water phase in the presence of an emulsifier. Mayonnaise typically has a thick and spoonable texture that is derived from the viscosity of the water phase and/or the high dispersed oil content.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Delena Feil

Last Updated:

Views: 6218

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (65 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Delena Feil

Birthday: 1998-08-29

Address: 747 Lubowitz Run, Sidmouth, HI 90646-5543

Phone: +99513241752844

Job: Design Supervisor

Hobby: Digital arts, Lacemaking, Air sports, Running, Scouting, Shooting, Puzzles

Introduction: My name is Delena Feil, I am a clean, splendid, calm, fancy, jolly, bright, faithful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.